FC Cincinnati score three unanswered goals to come from behind and win the Wild Card game 3-1 over Orlando City SC to kick off the 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs

cropped_20261119 ORLvsFCC JG2 0872-2

Soccer is serendipitous. Or, at the very least, poetic.

Three months ago, FC Cincinnati were looking to take three points on a trip to Orlando to keep a winning streak going. In that case, it was a tie game, but a late penalty overturned by VAR helped define the scoreline and leave FC Cincinnati with a draw rather than a win. A draw, and two fewer points, that had FCC been able to turn into a win and three points, would have led to them avoiding the wildcard game they found themselves in this stormy Thursday night in November. But there they were.

So it seems rather poetic that, in the same venue and against the same opponent three months later, an earned penalty against Orlando City SC helped spark the comeback that gave FC Cincinnati a playoff win and advancement in the MLS Cup Playoffs.

After falling behind 1-0 early in Thursday night’s win-or-go-home wildcard game against Orlando City SC, FC Cincinnati responded with three unanswered goals — including a brace from Evander — and kept their season alive with a 3-1 win at Inter & Co. Stadium. 

“Nice to keep playing,” FC Cincinnati Head Coach Pat Noonan said postgame, praising his squad's character. “I think the guys did an incredible job of just adapting, adjusting, and then winning an important game. So, I'm pleased about that for them and again, that we get to keep playing.”

“We didn't want to finish the season here,” FC Cincinnati midfielder and captain Evander said postgame. “We needed to step up tonight and give the fans this win, because it's been ups and downs during the season and we want to finish the season in a better way…so of course we are happy with a win tonight, but we have to enjoy tonight because we go again on Sunday.”

The poetry of that similarity is inexact, and frankly both hyper-dramatic and meaningless to how the game was played (I prefer romantic and elusive, but to each their own). Still, there is real beauty in this game because of it. The soccer gods, wherever they may rest and watch over these kinds of things, always seem to find a way to insert those little nuggets into the stories, and those little easter eggs make victories like these so sweet. 

So often this season, it has felt like when FC Cincinnati faced a challenging moment where fate had its say, the scales tipped against them. But during this victory on a cold, stormy evening in Central Florida, the scales tipped back. In August, it felt like a win was taken away; on Thursday, the penalty felt like a lifeline. A line FC Cincinnati held on to and didn’t give back. 

That was just the start; so much work was still left to do. But even in the moment, it felt like a shift. And to be clear, it was an earned penalty, for sure, but how often has it felt like a call that should’ve happened, didn’t? How often has a punishing blow been levied at the worst possible time? This year of all years, you wouldn’t have been blamed for expecting the worst. 

But that goal, followed by Evander’s second for a brace in the early stages of the second half, followed by a series of season-defining saves from Roman Celentano, followed by a goal-line clearance by Sami Gidi, who played every position possible, and who would then hustle down the field to score the third and final goal of the night moments later, felt earned in a different kind of way.  

Earned because of work they put in to secure it, particularly on the defensive side of the ball.

“Some of the video and some of the talking points (entering the game) were: ‘this is what it's going to need to look like on the road,” Noonan said of the approach to this game. “Put your body on the line in the right moments to make a play, and I think guys did a good job of that.” 

“I credit the entirety of the group for just being ready,” Noonan reiterated. “We have hard decisions…and I think tonight was one where you go down on the road ... we get the goal back, halftime we have a couple guys that are dealing with some issues that you have to make some unplanned changes, but that's life. That's been our reality, and I think the guys did an incredible job.

As mentioned, it was hardly a perfect night. It was certainly not one that went exactly to plan, but it was effective. It featured an FC Cincinnati squad that was on the road, damaged with in-game injuries, and waterlogged due to a rainstorm that only shares rivals with those outlined in — or by members of — Genesis. The Orange and Blue gritted out an “ugly” but effective performance. 

Roman Celentano was forced to make six saves, each of them more spectacular than the last. Sami Gidi cleared a ball off the line, and the midfield core put their bodies on the line time and time again to clear balls away from danger. 

Things went according to plan to an extent. They planned to play a physical game. They knew it would take an extra effort to win in an elimination game. It was expected they’d have to take advantage of their opportunities and rely on some of their stars to make things happen. 

But they didn’t plan to have to sub out two center backs out of the game at halftime due to injury. They didn’t plan to have no natural CBs in the XI to start the second half, and plan to move a midfielder back to CB to accommodate it. It’s not clear who, or how many, in the locker room knew that back home the city was reeling from the loss of a local hero, Fiona, but add that to the list of obstacles, too. They were prepared for a fight, and that was all they needed to overcome whatever odds they faced. 

“Obviously we did a lot of tactical work and technical work to get ready, but there were defenders' videos and team videos that were just showing moments of guys giving it everything, and I think that kind of gives us an insight on how you need to play these types of tournament games, knockout games because it's not always gonna be pretty,” keeper Roman Celentano said. “There's gonna be moments where guys need to slide in, guys need to get stuck in…and I think everyone showed grit and tenacity and a desire to win. Which, I think, is the most important thing right now.”

“We did a lot of very, very hard work in the last 11 or 12 days to put (ourselves) in a good situation for the game…and right now it’s just about being tough and having the right mentality,” Evander added. “We showed tonight that we didn't want to finish the season here. So I think the mentality was there, and the way that we managed the game was great.”

FC Cincinnati prepared for a battle, went to war, and came out the other side victorious. Their prize? Taking on #1-seeded Nashville SC in the next round of the MLS Cup Playoffs. A prize that doesn’t seem like one, but rest assured, it is compared to the alternative. 

Game One of that Best-of-3 series is set to kick off on Sunday afternoon, giving The Orange and Blue just two days to turn it around and be ready for another battle on the road. How FC Cincinnati prepare for that? The details aren't entirely clear, but the mentality will remain the same. 

And that is as good a starting point as any.

“We'll see,” Noonan said with a wily smile and a quiet laugh to himself when asked how they plan to prepare for the game. “We got a lot of guys banged up, and as you saw, to end the game, it was not an eleven that many would have imagined were seeing out that victory in the positions they were in. So, hopefully, we get some good news on some of the players, and if not, guys are going to do their best to turn it around and be ready to go in Nashville."